Claims

Ontario Appeal Court overturns decision that would have widened scope for taping defence medical examinations

In a 3-2 decision, the Ontario Court of Appeal has reversed a lower court ruling that would have allowed taping of defence medical examinations in most (if not all) cases where a request is made, based on an alleged “systemic bias” among health practitioners who undertake medical examinations for the defence.  In doing so, the […]

By Canadian Underwriter | April 23, 2010

3 min read

Canadian P&C industry over-relying on use of one vendor-provided catastrophe model: KPMG study

There is a potential systemic risk in the use of catastrophe models in Canada because of the property and casualty industry’s “extensive reliance on vendor-provided catastrophe models, particularly with extensive reliance on one vendor in Canada,” KPMG says in research contracted by the Insurance Bureau of Canada (IBC). Rachel Dutil of KPMG LLG shared preliminary […]

By Canadian Underwriter | April 22, 2010

2 min read

Ontario court re-asserts limits on how much plaintiff’s counsel can help client during discovery

The Ontario Superior Court recently re-asserted the limits of how much a plaintiff’s counsel can help his or her client during an examination for discovery in an action concerning a motor vehicle accident.In Michael Madonis v. Julian G. Dezotti and Donna L. Dezotti, counsel for the plaintiff (Madonis) made numerous attempts to provide answers on […]

By Canadian Underwriter | April 21, 2010

2 min read

Ontario Court of Appeal finds trial judge did not ‘double deduct’ IRBs from jury award

As long as a trial judge has not directed a jury to deduct income replacement benefits (IRBs) from their jury award, the trial judge may deduct IRBs from the jury award without fear of “double deduction,” the Ontario’s Court of Appeal has ruled.In Karamzadeh v. Pierre, Heydar Karamzadeh was found by the Ontario Superior Court […]

By Canadian Underwriter | April 19, 2010

2 min read